10 Best Eyebrow Pencils to Achieve Your Ideal Brows

Eyebrows are one of the most important features of your face. They frame your eyes, balance your features, and express your emotions. Whether you have thick, thin, sparse, or unruly brows, there is an eyebrow pencil that can help you shape, fill, and define them.

Eyebrow pencils are easy to use, versatile, and affordable. They come in different shapes, sizes, colors, and formulas to suit your preferences and needs. But with so many options available, how do you choose the best one for you?

In this blog post, we will guide you through the factors to consider when choosing an eyebrow pencil, and share our top 10 picks for the best eyebrow pencils in the market. We will also answer some frequently asked questions about eyebrow pencils at the end of the article.

How to Choose an Eyebrow Pencil

When choosing an eyebrow pencil, you should consider the following factors:

  • Type: There are two main types of eyebrow pencils: retractable and sharpenable. Retractable pencils have a twist-up mechanism that allows you to adjust the length of the pencil tip. They are convenient and easy to use, but they may break or run out faster. Sharpenable pencils have a wooden or plastic casing that you need to sharpen with a sharpener. They are more durable and precise, but they may require more maintenance and waste more product.
  • Tip: The shape and size of the pencil tip affect the application and the final result. There are three common tip styles: fine, angled, and round. Fine tips are ideal for drawing thin, hair-like strokes and creating a natural look. Angled tips are great for outlining and filling in large areas and creating a defined look. Round tips are suitable for blending and shading and creating a soft look.
  • Color: The color of the eyebrow pencil should match or complement your natural brow color and hair color. A general rule of thumb is to choose a shade that is one or two shades lighter or darker than your natural brow color, depending on the look you want to achieve. For a natural look, go for a lighter shade. For a bold look, go for a darker shade. You can also mix and match different shades to create dimension and contrast.
  • Formula: The formula of the eyebrow pencil affects the texture, pigmentation, and longevity of the product. There are three common formula types: wax-based, powder-based, and gel-based. Wax-based pencils have a creamy and smooth texture that glides on easily and adheres well to the skin and hair. They are highly pigmented and long-lasting, but they may smudge or melt in hot or humid conditions. Powder-based pencils have a dry and powdery texture that blends well and creates a soft and matte finish. They are moderately pigmented and long-wearing, but they may fade or flake over time. Gel-based pencils have a wet and gel-like texture that sets quickly and creates a glossy and waterproof finish. They are lightly pigmented and ultra-long-lasting, but they may dry out or clump if not applied carefully.
  • Features: Some eyebrow pencils have additional features that enhance their functionality and performance. For example, some pencils have a brush attachment that helps you comb, groom, and blend your brows. Some pencils have a spoolie attachment that helps you fluff and shape your brows. Some pencils have a dual-ended design that offers two different colors or formulas in one product. Some pencils have a refillable design that allows you to replace the cartridge when it runs out.

10 Best Eyebrow Pencils to Buy Online

Based on the factors mentioned above, we have selected and ranked the 10 best eyebrow pencils that you can buy online. We have also included a brief review of each product, highlighting its pros and cons.

1. Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil Waterproof Eyebrow Definer

Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil Waterproof Eyebrow Definer is our top pick for the best eyebrow pencil overall. It is a retractable pencil with a fine tip that allows you to draw precise, hair-like strokes and create a natural and realistic look. It has a creamy and pigmented formula that glides on smoothly and lasts up to 12 hours. It also has a spoolie attachment that helps you blend and shape your brows. It comes in 12 shades that suit various brow colors and skin tones.

Pros:

  • Fine tip for precision and naturalness
  • Creamy and pigmented formula for smoothness and longevity
  • Spoolie attachment for blending and shaping
  • 12 shades for versatility and compatibility

Cons:

  • Expensive
  • May break or run out quickly

2. Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz is our runner-up for the best eyebrow pencil overall. It is a retractable pencil with a fine tip that allows you to draw thin, hair-like strokes and create a natural and realistic look. It has a wax-based formula that adheres well to the skin and hair and lasts all day. It also has a spoolie attachment that helps you comb and groom your brows. It comes in 10 shades that suit various brow colors and skin tones.

Pros:

  • Fine tip for precision and naturalness
  • Wax-based formula for adherence and longevity
  • Spoolie attachment for combing and grooming
  • 10 shades for versatility and compatibility

Cons:

  • Expensive
  • May break or run out quickly

3. Fenty Beauty Brow MVP Ultra Fine Brow Pencil & Styler

Fenty Beauty Brow MVP Ultra Fine Brow Pencil & Styler is our top pick for the best waterproof eyebrow pencil. It is a retractable pencil with a fine tip that allows you to draw thin, hair-like strokes and create a natural and realistic look. It has a gel-based formula that sets quickly and creates a waterproof and smudge-proof finish. It also has a unique paddle brush attachment that helps you fluff and shape your brows. It comes in 14 shades that suit various brow colors and skin tones.

Pros:

  • Fine tip for precision and naturalness
  • Gel-based formula for waterproofness and smudge-proofness
  • Paddle brush attachment for fluffing and shaping
  • 14 shades for versatility and compatibility

Cons:

  • Expensive
  • May dry out or clump if not applied carefully

4. NYX Professional Makeup Eyebrow Pomade

NYX Professional Makeup Eyebrow Pomade is our top pick for the best drugstore eyebrow pencil. It is a sharpenable pencil with a round tip that allows you to blend and shade your brows and create a soft and natural look. It has a powder-based formula that creates a soft and matte finish and lasts up to 12 hours. It also has a spoolie attachment that helps you comb and groom your brows. It comes in 8 shades that suit various brow colors and skin tones.

Pros:

  • Affordable
  • Round tip for blending and shading
  • Powder-based formula for softness and matte finish
  • Spoolie attachment for combing and grooming
  • 8 shades for versatility and compatibility

Cons:

  • May require sharpening and maintenance
  • May fade or flake over time

5. Kosas Defining Eyebrow Pencil

Kosas Defining Eyebrow Pencil is our top pick for the best vegan eyebrow pencil. It is a retractable pencil with an angled tip that allows you to outline and fill in your brows and create a defined and polished look. It has a wax-based formula that glides on smoothly and creates a natural and buildable finish. It also has a spoolie attachment that helps you blend and shape your brows. It comes in 6 shades that suit various brow colors and skin tones. It is also cruelty-free, gluten-free, and paraben-free.

Pros:

  • Vegan and cruelty-free
  • Angled tip for outlining and filling
  • Wax-based formula for smoothness and buildability
  • Spoolie attachment for blending and shaping
  • 6 shades for versatility and compatibility

Cons:

  • Expensive
  • May smudge or melt in hot or humid conditions

6. Maybelline Tattoo Brow 36HR Eyebrow Pencil

Maybelline Tattoo Brow 36HR Eyebrow Pencil is our top pick for the best long-lasting eyebrow pencil. It is a retractable pencil with a fine tip that allows you to draw thin, hair-like strokes and create a natural and realistic look. It has a gel-based formula that sets quickly and creates a waterproof and smudge-proof finish that lasts up to 36 hours. It also has a spoolie attachment that helps you fluff and shape your brows. It comes in 6 shades that suit various brow colors and skin tones.

Pros:

  • Affordable
  • Fine tip for precision and naturalness
  • Gel-based formula for waterproofness and smudge-proofness
  • Spoolie attachment for fluffing and shaping
  • 6 shades for versatility and compatibility

Cons:

  • May dry out or clump if not applied carefully
  • May be difficult to remove.

7. Gucci Crayon Définition Sourcils Powder Eyebrow Pencil

Gucci Crayon Définition Sourcils Powder Eyebrow Pencil is our top pick for the best luxury eyebrow pencil. It is a sharpenable pencil with a round tip that allows you to blend and shade your brows and create a soft and natural look. It has a powder-based formula that creates a soft and matte finish and lasts up to 12 hours. It also has a brush attachment that helps you comb and groom your brows. It comes in 6 shades that suit various brow colors and skin tones. It is also enriched with natural waxes and oils that nourish and condition your brows.

Pros:

  • Luxury and high-quality
  • Round tip for blending and shading
  • Powder-based formula for softness and matte finish
  • Brush attachment for combing and grooming
  • 6 shades for versatility and compatibility
  • Natural waxes and oils for nourishment and conditioning

Cons:

  • Very expensive
  • May require sharpening and maintenance
  • May fade or flake over time

8. Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil

[Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil] is our top pick for the best dual-ended eyebrow pencil. It is a retractable pencil with an angled tip that allows you to outline and fill in your brows and create a defined and polished look. It has a wax-based formula that glides on smoothly and creates a natural and buildable finish. It also has a powder-based formula that blends well and creates a soft and matte finish. It also has a spoolie attachment that helps you blend and shape your brows. It comes in 9 shades that suit various brow colors and skin tones.

Pros:

  • Dual-ended design for versatility and convenience
  • Angled tip for outlining and filling
  • Wax-based formula for smoothness and buildability
  • Powder-based formula for softness and matte finish
  • Spoolie attachment for blending and shaping
  • 9 shades for versatility and compatibility

Cons:

  • Expensive
  • May break or run out quickly
  • May smudge or melt in hot or humid conditions

9. Charlotte Tilbury Brow Lift Eyebrow Pencil

Charlotte Tilbury Brow Lift Eyebrow Pencil is our top pick for the best 3-in-1 eyebrow pencil. It is a sharpenable pencil with an angled tip that allows you to outline and fill in your brows and create a defined and polished look. It also has a highlighter attachment that helps you lift and brighten your brow bone and create an illusion of fuller and thicker brows. It also has a brush attachment that helps you comb and groom your brows. It comes in 8 shades that suit various brow colors and skin tones.

Pros:

  • 3-in-1 design for versatility and convenience
  • Angled tip for outlining and filling
  • Highlighter attachment for lifting and brightening
  • Brush attachment for combing and grooming
  • 8 shades for versatility and compatibility

Cons:

  • Expensive
  • May require sharpening and maintenance
  • May fade or flake over time

10. L’Oreal Paris Brow Stylist Definer Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil

L’Oreal Paris Brow Stylist Definer Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil is our top pick for the best budget eyebrow pencil. It is a retractable pencil with a fine tip that allows you to draw thin, hair-like strokes and create a natural and realistic look. It has a gel-based formula that sets quickly and creates a waterproof and smudge-proof finish. It also has a spoolie attachment that helps you fluff and shape your brows. It comes in 7 shades that suit various brow colors and skin tones.

Pros:

  • Very affordable
  • Fine tip for precision and naturalness
  • Gel-based formula for waterproofness and smudge-proofness
  • Spoolie attachment for fluffing and shaping
  • 7 shades for versatility and compatibility

Cons:

  • May dry out or clump if not applied carefully
  • May be difficult to remove

Frequently Asked Questions About Eyebrow Pencils

Here are some of the most common questions that people have about eyebrow pencils, and our answers to them.

Q: How do I use an eyebrow pencil?

A: Here are the basic steps to use an eyebrow pencil:

  • Start with clean and dry brows. You can also apply a primer or a brow gel to prep your brows and make them easier to work with.
  • Choose an eyebrow pencil that matches or complements your natural brow color and hair color. You can also use two different shades to create dimension and contrast.
  • Use the pencil to outline the shape of your brows, following your natural arch and length. You can also use a stencil or a ruler to guide you.
  • Use the pencil to fill in any sparse or bald areas, using light and short strokes that mimic your natural hair growth. You can also use the pencil to create a gradient effect, making the inner part of your brows lighter and the outer part darker.
  • Use the brush or spoolie attachment to blend and soften the pencil strokes, and create a more natural and seamless look. You can also use the brush or spoolie to fluff and shape your brows.
  • Use the highlighter attachment to apply a light and shimmery shade under your brow bone, and blend it well. This will help you lift and brighten your brows, and create an illusion of fuller and thicker brows.
  • Use a brow gel or a setting spray to seal and set your brows, and make them last longer.

Q: How do I choose the right eyebrow pencil for me?

A: When choosing an eyebrow pencil, you should consider the following factors:

  • Type: Choose between retractable and sharpenable pencils, depending on your preference and convenience.
  • Tip: Choose between fine, angled, and round tips, depending on the look you want to achieve and the level of precision and control you need.
  • Color: Choose a shade that matches or complements your natural brow color and hair color, depending on the look you want to achieve and the level of contrast you want to create.
  • Formula: Choose between wax-based, powder-based, and gel-based formulas, depending on the texture, pigmentation, and longevity you want.
  • Features: Choose an eyebrow pencil that has additional features that enhance its functionality and performance, such as a brush, spoolie, highlighter, dual-ended, or refillable design.

Q: How do I sharpen an eyebrow pencil?

A: To sharpen an eyebrow pencil, you need a sharpener that is designed for makeup pencils. You can also use a regular pencil sharpener, but make sure it is clean and sharp. Here are the steps to sharpen an eyebrow pencil:

  • Freeze the pencil for about 15 minutes before sharpening. This will help the pencil to harden and prevent it from breaking or crumbling.
  • Twist the pencil gently in the sharpener, applying light pressure. Do not over-sharpen or under-sharpen the pencil, as this may affect the application and the result.
  • Clean the sharpener after each use, and remove any residue or shavings. You can use a cotton swab or a tissue to do this.

Q: How do I remove an eyebrow pencil?

A: To remove an eyebrow pencil, you need a makeup remover that is suitable for your skin type and the formula of the pencil. You can also use a gentle cleanser, oil, or micellar water. Here are the steps to remove an eyebrow pencil:

  • Soak a cotton pad or a tissue with the makeup remover of your choice.
  • Gently wipe the cotton pad or tissue over your brows, following the direction of your hair growth. Do not rub or tug your brows, as this may damage or irritate your skin and hair.
  • Repeat until all the pencil is removed, and your brows are clean and clear.
  • Rinse your face with water, and pat it dry with a towel.
  • Apply a moisturizer or a serum to hydrate and nourish your skin and brows.

Conclusion

Eyebrow pencils are one of the most essential and versatile tools for your brow game. They can help you shape, fill, and define your brows, and create various looks, from natural to bold. They can also enhance your overall appearance, and boost your confidence and mood.

We hope that this blog post has helped you learn more about eyebrow pencils, and how to choose and use them. We also hope that you have found your ideal eyebrow pencil from our list of the 10 best eyebrow pencils in the market.

If you have any questions, comments, or suggestions, please feel free to leave them below. We would love to hear from you and help you out.

Thank you for reading, and happy brow-ing! 

Love this? Share:

In This Post:

In This Post: